October 14, 2020

By Steven Jonas, MD, MPH     

"Either this nation shall kill racism, or racism shall kill this nation."

— S. Jonas, August, 2018

INTRODUCTION

The argument presented in this column is entirely hypothetical. I do not have access to any "inside" information that would prove it to be true. But it might be. For, as the tapes presented in Bob Woodward's book tell us, entirely contrary to what I had concluded at the time, Trump did understand the nature of the coming onslaught, and he understood it very well.  And if so, why did he respond to it the way he did? For if he had adopted standard public health measures at the beginning, he likely would have been on the glide-path to re-election. But obviously he didn't see it that way, even if he did indeed understand the biology and the epidemiology of the disease.

Among the answers to the "why did he do what he did" question have been: stupidity, rigidity, "concern with the market," my own "magical thinking" explanation, political insularity, and so forth. This column presents another possible explanation: that back in January, Trump and his closest advisors (like his son, son-in-law, Bill Barr, Rudy Giuliani, and Stephen Miller), focusing entirely on his chances for re-election, had for a variety of reasons unknown to the outside world concluded that as things stood then his chances of winning were not great. And thus, they consciously came up with the "Chaos Strategy" that I describe below, as providing his only path to victory. 

So far, they have certainly managed to create chaos, on a variety of fronts. Right now, the chances of its working electorally do not seem too good. But a major part of the strategy is of course to create chaos in the voting and the vote-counting. The implementation of that part of it is clearly underway. In terms of achieving success in the sense that Trump would actually "win" the election in the conventional sense, well no (or hell, NO). But could he remain in the Presidency after noon on Jan. 20, 2021, through the implementation of a set of legal and extra-legal measures that can be lumped together under the rubric of "Stealing the Vote?"  That is very much still possible. And so, to the presentation of the hypothesis.

The Trump/Barr Chaos Hypothesis 

What has happened this year under Trump, vis-à-vis the COVID19 pandemic (to which I refer as the Trumpidemic2020[C]) and the Trump response to it, and the impending Presidential election and the Trump response to it, seem to be random events, totally unrelated to each other. Of course, the timing of this particular pandemic was indeed a random event. Pandemics do occur regularly and have throughout human history. But their nature, timing, and intensity are random (at least seemingly so). On the surface, Trump's response to it, which has been chronicled in my columns and many, many other places since the impending disaster first made itself known in this country in January, 2020 has indeed been seemingly random, based on Trump's idiocy and etc. 

The response in terms of the nation's health has been particularly ineffective, compared with that in most other developed countries (other than Sweden), at least up to now (see the right-wing led United Kingdom).  In fact, the Trumpian response has been disease-generative. Second in terms of responses has been what I have characterized as Bill Barr's drive towards fascism and Trump's "useful idiot" role in that drive, certainly reinforced by the wide-spread focus (other than among the Trumpublicans©) on finally coming to terms with the national blight of institutional racism. This set of events and the Barr-generated Federal response to it play right into Trump's own obvious fascination with dictatorship. Finally, there is the also obvious Trump/Republican planning to suppress the vote and disrupt the balloting-and-counting-of-them for the election (as mentioned above: Greg Palast: How Trump Stole 2020). 

OK. Seemingly random factors/events, not connected to each other, at least in any causative, if-then-if-then, sense. But suppose they are not random. "Chaos" is defined by multiple dictionaries as a "state of utter confusion." In the ordinary sense, it would be considered to be the opposite of "planned," that is organized, designed specifically to meet a set of defined needs. But could chaos itself be planned, or at least planned for? That is what I am speculating on here. Indeed, I am speculating that the series of events and circumstances listed above, including the unpredictable one, the pandemic, were, are, and will be linked together by Barr/Trump in order to produce a Trump victory and then lead to the imposition of a fascist state in our nation. Wild? Yes. But bear with me. 

The first intimations that a possible new pandemic was brewing in China appeared sometime in the fall of 2019. The CDC issued an official report on it in late December, 2019.  Exactly when the first official notice appeared in a Presidential Daily Brief is unclear, but it was sometime in January. It is certainly unclear as to when, and if, Trump saw those reports. But the knowledge of an impending pandemic wasn't secret, for, presumably with no access to the intelligence reports that were already on the President's desk, Joe Biden published a column in USA Today on January 27, 2020 that warned of it. Whatever Trump did and did not see in terms of PDBs and warnings from the CDC, as noted above we know from the tapes transcribed in Bob Woodward's book that Trump understood very well a) what the nature of the virus was and b) what the potential danger for the nation was. 

We also know that Trump's public posturing during February/March was a) that it was insignificant, b) that it would all go away by itself, c) that any warnings of something serious coming constituted a Democratic plot to make him look bad (of course it was a "hoax," like the Mueller Report, impeachment, and so on and so forth), and d) that a "China travel ban" (that happened to leak like an old wooden row boat left out in the weather much too long, that Trumpannity still harp on --- my, that harp is getting worn) would solve the problem. Which it didn't. 

And so, the pandemic proceeded to become the Trumpidemic2020©, which has not only had the very tragic health/disease outcomes for so many people and so many families, but the economic tragedies for so many too. Compounding this are the George Floyd police-murder and its sequelae, leading to the national campaign for racial justice. To which, of course, Trump has responded with his not-at-all camouflaged racist "law and order" counter-campaign. And on top of this is Trump's Steal the Election campaign through legal (Republican voter-suppression/legal challenges to vote-counting) and illegal (voter-intimidation and potential paper ballot destruction efforts) methods plus "the-vote-is-rigged" propaganda, to undermine the legitimacy of the vote in the minds of his supporters. 

Now most interpretations of what is going on see these events, that is: a) the appearance of the pandemic; b) Trump's response to it, basically a combination of "it will just magically go away" and "the nation has to grin and bear it;" c) an active anti-public-health-approach campaign (capped figuratively by his ripping off his mask upon arriving back at the White House from the Walter Reed Hospital on Oct. 5); d) his increasingly intensive campaign against the legitimacy of the 2020 vote; as unconnected. But supposing, just supposing, they aren't. Bear with me. Here's a possible sequence of events designed to lead inexorably to the establishment of a fascist state governing the United States, which has obviously been the goal of Bill Barr and the ruling class sector he represents for quite some time. For now, they are just repeated and summarized here. 

A) As noted above, Trump and his people realize very early on, certainly by January 2020, that he is going to have a difficult time winning re-election, particularly if the Democratic candidate were to be Joe Biden. That is why earlier they went after him in what became the "Ukraine Plot" which led to Trump’s impeachment. (Certainly, no original thinking on my part there.) And through the impeachment process the Ukraine Plot becomes undone (as much as Hannity et al try to hold it together, and still do). And of course, Joe Biden is the Democratic nominee. 

B) The impending pandemic appears, like a gift from heaven. And contrary to the case I made with the concept of Trump's "magical thinking," that, for example, he could not get into his head the concept of a virus and how much damage it could do to the U.S. population (as I stated repeatedly throughout the Spring and into the summer), as recorded by the Woodward tapes, he understood it very well.

C) He, Barr, and other members of his inner circle come up with his plan-to-win: create chaos, and continue to do it right though the election and its aftermath. As for Trump's unitary focus on getting back into the White House on the afternoon of January 20, 2021, the reasons are well-known. He likes the idea of being Dictator. He would like to stay out of prison, state, Federal or both, without having to leave the country. He likes the idea of a racism-based fascism, and Bill Barr surely likes fascism, racism-based or not. 

D) And so, step 1 of the Chaos-creation-plan is to intentionally let the pandemic get totally out-of-control. Step 2 falls into their laps with the George Floyd murder and the rapidly-developing movement to finally deal with the Doctrine of White Supremacy which has dominated the political-economy of this country since the end of Reconstruction. Trump does nothing positively to deal with it, but does everything he can to stir up violence around it: more chaos. 

E) And then, even more chaos in the plan to disrupt the elections, before, during and after, both legally and with potential violence --- sending his "guards" to the polling places --- if necessary. 

F) And this could well lead inexorably to Trump remaining-in-place which, they had determined, he could not otherwise do.

Can I prove this hypothesis? Of course, not (at least not at this time). But the indicators are there. And who knows? If their plan doesn't work and Trump loses, it could all come out in the wash as early as next year. If Trump wins, but somewhere down the road fascism is destroyed and Constitutional Democracy is restored, then it could all be revealed at that time. 

But, final consideration, this whole thing would require planning, and Bob Woodward tells us that Trump cannot plan. Ah yes, he cannot plan for anything positive, like getting the pandemic under control by using the standard public health measures that have been so successful in virtually every other advanced capitalist country, and some not-so-advanced ones as well. But negative planning has been a major element in his life. He has planned very well, over-and-over again, to get through adversities any of which would have sunk just about anyone else. In fact, he did the negative planning so well that despite his incredibly horrible track record as a businessman, with no education to speak of, he managed to become President of the United States. So, it is conceivable, with help from his friends Bill Barr and Stephen Miller and Rudy Giuliani and his "boys," that he could have planned this one --- on a very large scale indeed --- too.

We shall see, one way or the other.

     -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Note:  An earlier version of this column was published on Oct. 7, 2020, at OpEdNews.

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------————

Postscript, 10/8/20: As if to provide further evidence that my speculation above may in fact reflect reality, today Mike Schmidt and Katie Benner of The New York Times wrote that in an unprecedented move Barr ordered "inquiries into voter fraud before the election [emphasis added]." As the article says: "For decades, federal prosecutors have been told not mount election fraud investigations in the final months before an election for fear they could depress turnout or erode confidence in the results [emphasis added] . . . possibly 'chilling legitimate voting and campaign activities. . .' ".  Three guesses as to why Barr is doing this.

Postscript, 10/11/20: It's happening, folks, right in front of our eyes.  Trump/Barr and their crew are openly starting to implement their plan to steal the election.  That Trump, currently deep into what is called " 'roid rage" is attacking even Barr is irrelevant.  They will pull him back in and move forward with determination.  As it happens, the majority of the ruling class of this country is more-and-more turning against Trump (e.g., see the reports on the Biden fund-raising from "Wall Street").  But if they don't get their legal act together as well as organizing on the ground to stop Trump’s goons (from, say, simply tearing up masses of paper ballots so that they could never be counted), it is going to be all over.  Of course, I will be writing more on this down the road.  And of course, I hope that I am actually entirely wrong with what I have to say in this column.

     ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------—-

Steven Jonas, MD, MPH, MS is a Professor Emeritus of Preventive Medicine at StonyBrookMedicine (NY) and author/co-author/editor/co-editor of over 35 books.  In addition to his position on OpEdNews.com  as a “Trusted Author,” he is a contributor to Reader Supported News/Writing for Godot; buzzflash.com and From The G-Man.  His own political website, stevenjonaspolitics.com, will eventually be an archive of the close to 1000 political columns he has published since 2004.  He is also a triathlete (36 seasons, 256 multi-sport races; not racing in the Year of the COVID-19 pandemic).

Dr. Jonas’ latest book is Ending the ‘Drug War’; Solving the Drug Problem: The Public Health Approach, Brewster, NY: Punto Press Publishing, (Brewster, NY, 2016, available on Kindle from Amazon, and also in hardcover from Amazon). 

Please support BuzzFlash financially if you want to help defeat Donald Trump, who is endangering our lives. BuzzFlash exposes Trump's corruption and his dismantling of our democracy. Don't just pass this over. Click and scroll down donation page to receive a gift as our gratitude.

Follow BuzzFlash on @twitter

Continue the conversation at the BuzzFlash Nation group on Facebook